Cheesy pizzas, savory pasta and folded sandwiches anchor Italian food at Coterie Pizza in Indiana, with pickup available for your meal.
Order online8" Hot Hny
$13.08
An eight-inch pizza with a sweet-spicy hot honey finish.
“Absolutely fantastic quality of fresh dough, sauce, and cheese. Chris was extremely friendly and talked with us quite a bit about their process and ingredients. The Hot Honey was perfect, really focused on the core flavors like a margarita but with that extra spice.”
Cajun Pizza
$13.45
A spicy stone-oven pizza with chicken, sausage, and two kinds of peppers.
“I'm new to Garrett. Moved here in April 2026. I'm trying out all the restaurants & coffee shops here & giving my full honest opinion. The pizza here was pretty great! I had the Spicy Cajun Pizza. The pizzas are 12" & I could only eat half, since It made me full.😂 The employees are super friendly & professional. If someone on Google complains about the employees are bad here, it's not the employees, but the reviewer.”
Chicken Bacon Pizza
$13.45
Stone-oven pizza with chicken, smoked bacon, and mozzarella.
“This food was sooo good. We got the chicken and bacon pizza with extra cheese, half bbq and half ranch. Cheese bread with beer cheese. Service was quick and Beth was great. Definitely recommend this hidden gem!”
Gluten Free Chicken Bacon
$15.25
Pizza with chicken, bacon, mozzarella, and your choice of sauce.
“Our servers are always great. The pizza is amazing. On Wednesdays they have a special with a different crust. The hot honey pizza and brisket Pizza are delicious. Our personal favorites though are chicken/bacon/ ranch as well as ricotta/ pepperoni/ and mushroom. There is a self serve beer wall and local art to look at while you eat as well.”
Coterie Pizza serves Italian food spanning red-sauce pizzas, creamy white pies, pasta and folded sandwiches. You'll also find a salad with mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, fresh basil and a balsamic drizzle.
Chicken Bacon pairs roasted chicken with cherry-smoked bacon; Mushroom Medley layers mushrooms, cheeses and herbs. Classic Penne is baked in cast iron with house marinara, melted mozzarella and creamy ricotta.
Visit Coterie Pizza in Indiana for pickup, dine-in or delivery. Brisket is a smoky stone-oven pie topped with brisket burnt ends, mushrooms, marinated onions and house-made BBQ sauce.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
