Skip to main content
Margherita Pizza

Pizza in Indiana

Stone-oven pizza with meat and vegetable toppings awaits you at Coterie Pizza in Indiana, where you can order for pickup.

Order online

Cheese Pizza

Cheese Pizza

$11.50

Stone-oven pizza with house red sauce and melted mozzarella.

“Absolutely delicious!!! They have an amazing crust, quality toppings !! A must try pizza experience !!!”

8" Chz

$10.28

An 8-inch pizza topped with cheese on a baked crust.

“This place is amazing! The pizza is definitely one of our favorites in the area! Made a little side trip when coming home from Ft Wayne tonight and it's oh, so worth it! The service is great and the pizza is even better! Get the Mexican Street Corn Pizza while it's available for the next 3 months or so! Go get some!”

Gluten Free Cheese Pizza

$13.25

A cheese pizza with a plain cheese topping.

“Absolutely delicious pizza. The hot honey is the right amount of spicy and sweet. The mushroom medley is on point with a nice variety of mushrooms. Many different options that do not contain a tomato based sauce which is nice. If you're lucky enough to find the street corn pizza in stock (when in season) it is a culinary treat. Bursts of sweet corn combined with salty bacon and a slightly tangy aioli, chef's kiss! Great place for amazing pizza.”

Build-Your-Own Pizza

Specialty Pizzas

16" Chicken Bacon

$15.95

A 16-inch pizza with chicken, bacon, mozzarella, and a sauce choice.

“Our servers are always great. The pizza is amazing. On Wednesdays they have a special with a different crust. The hot honey pizza and brisket Pizza are delicious. Our personal favorites though are chicken/bacon/ ranch as well as ricotta/ pepperoni/ and mushroom. There is a self serve beer wall and local art to look at while you eat as well.”

Meet Coterie Pizza

At Coterie Pizza, your pizza can have house red sauce and melted mozzarella on an Italian crust, or come as a creamy white pie with spinach, artichokes and dollops of ricotta over mozzarella.

Chicken Bacon pairs roasted chicken with cherry-smoked bacon. Hot Honey adds ricotta, pepperoni and a spicy honey drizzle. Brisket features burnt ends, marinated onions and house-made BBQ sauce.

Visit Coterie Pizza in Indiana for pickup, dine-in or delivery. Mushroom Medley combines wild mushrooms, smoked mozzarella, Parmesan and Romano with aromatic herbs in an earthy stone-oven pie.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular pizza options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Cheese Pizza — A house Italian-style crust holds red sauce and melted mozzarella; the menu description also allows diners to build it with toppings.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for pizza throughout the Indiana area. Order your pizza online for convenient pickup or delivery.