Best Pizza in Garrett

Pizza Is a Food to Share

Order online

Featured

View menu

Where We Started

Chris Zaugg was making pizzas in his backyard oven for anyone who came over. His next door neighbor Harvey loved pizza, the two families became friends, and that's how we ended up opening in Garrett.

Read our story

The Stone Oven

Every pizza goes through our master crafted Italian stone oven. Try the Margherita. The crust comes out firm with a slight chew.

Order online

Beer Cheese and Bread

Start with the beer cheese. Order it alongside a pizza and you'll likely have leftovers to take home.

Build Your Own

Start with cheese and add what you like. Green peppers, onions and mushrooms are on the list, and we have whole Kalamata olives too.

Pour Your Own Beer

Seat yourself, and our team will walk you through the beer wall. You get a bracelet, scan it at the tap and pay by the ounce. Beer and wine are both on tap.

We drive from Fort Wayne just to get their pizza 🍕 and beer bread (with beer 🧀 cheese, yum!). The place is always spotless and all the servers are delightful. It's self-serve, all-you-can-drink soft drinks. There's also beers and wine on tap (self-serve), but I don't drink so I don't know how that works.

Mari O.

Great local place with the freshest ingredients. Service is VERY friendly. Atmosphere is modern and cool. Beer Cheese - $6.99 - Very good and very filling. It may cause you to have leftovers of your pizza. 5/5 stars. Chicken Bruschetta Pizza - $13.35 - I thought the balsamic vinegar would be overpowering, but it was not. Good balance and good amount of toppings. 5/5 stars. Mushroom Medley - $13.35 - Love this pizza, but I'm also partial to mushroom pizzas. 5/5 stars. Cheese - $11.25 -…

Charissa H.

Excellent, fast,attentive service. Best pizza I've ever had in my 85 years. Love the "build your own" choice for getting exactly what you want at that moment. I was nervous about trying one of specialty pizzas, since "hot honey" sounded weird to me. But I risked it. FANTASTIC! Everyone should try it once.

Lillian S.

First time at Coterie pizza and I must say it's well worth the trip. Had a traditional Margarita pizza. Great flavor and the crust was firm with a slight chew we ended up getting a cajun pizza, chicken, seasoned beef, green peppers, hot peppers and a spicy cajun drizzle. You'll definitely feel the heat on this one. Lastly we got a traditional pepperoni, unfortunately they we out of honey so well have to get the hot honey pepperoni next time.

Victor R.

Super! I read the reviews and had to try it on my way to Ft. Wayne. I ordered the beer cheese appetizer, hot honey, chicken & bacon, Margarita, and brisket pizzas with the idea of tasting and then taking most of it home. The beer cheese is amazing! It also re-heated ok. Favorite was the chicken & bacon with BBQ sauce. I don't usually like pizza without red sauce, but these pizzas were an exception. Ironically, my least favorite was the margarita. They were all great, though, and some of the…

Diana M.

Coterie Pizza Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!

Join now

Frequently Asked Questions

What are you known for?

We’re known for pizza with toppings like hot honey, brisket, and mushrooms, alongside Italian-inspired pasta, salads, and sandwiches in Indiana.

Italian Food: Italian-inspired dishes span specialty pizzas, penne pasta, a sandwich, and caprese salad, with gluten-free pizza options available. Examples include 16" Chicken Bruschetta, Gluten Free Mushroom Medley, Classic Penne, Rustic Penne, Italian Sandwich, and Caprese Salad.
Pizza: Pizzas range from classic cheese to brisket, hot honey, and vegetable toppings, with multiple sizes and gluten-free options. Examples include Cheese Pizza, 16" Brisket, 8" Hot Hny, 16" Spinach Artichoke, Gluten Free Mushroom Medley, and 12" Pep.
Salads: Salads include house, Greek, Caesar, Italian chopped, and caprese styles, with half and full portions for house and Greek options. Examples include Half House, Full House, Greek Goddess, Coterie Caesar, Italian Chop Salad, and Caprese Salad.
Sandwiches: Sandwiches cover vegetable, sausage, Italian-style, and ham-and-cheese options. Examples include Veggie Sandwich, Sausage Sandwich, Italian Sandwich, and Ham and Cheese Sandwich.
Pasta: Pasta options feature classic and rustic penne alongside beer cheese and bacon. Examples include Classic Penne, Rustic Penne, and Beer Cheese and Bacon.

What meals do you serve?

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Do you offer delivery or takeout?

Yes, we offer Delivery and Takeout

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Butler Center, Cedar, Garrett, Saint Johns, Altona, New Era, Swan, Laotto, Auburn, Avilla, Cedar Canyons, Corunna, Ari, Sedan, Huntertown, Cedar Shores, Ege, Lisbon, Waterloo, and DeKalb County.